Saturday, October 28, 2006

Total Depravity. Unconditional Election. Limited Atonement. Irresistible Grace. Perseverance of the Saints. These are the five theological terms used by Calvinists to describe, in brief, what they believe. Conveniently, it fits together to make the acronym T.U.L.I.P., which sounds nice and flowery, but does nothing more than hide the cruelty of the doctrine behind a bouquet of literacy. Some Calvinists have realized that these terms, especially the one about depravity, aren't exactly seeker-friendly, so they've sought out softer words. Choices abound, but in general, the words still jab like a red-hot poker. This begs the question, "If they're going to offend, why not just say what they mean?" Each of these five points has one word that's at least nine letters long. Unconditional, for example, is thirteen characters. For something as important as salvation, we need to cut through as much of the fat as possible. I propose a new acronym, one that both fits the Calvinist doctrines as a whole and also explains in layman's terms what they mean.

Handpicked: This one used to be called Unconditional Election, and was eleven letters longer in its original incarnation. Aristocracy would also be a fitting term if it was just a bit shorter. In brief, Calvinists believe that God picks his children, without any input from them. You cannot seek to be saved, nor can you repent unless God allows you. Like an apple, there's only two ways off the tree: either you're handpicked, or you go down.

Once Saved, Always Saved: That's it. Many Calvinists already embrace this term, which makes this step an abbreviated one. You can't get much simpler than once saved, always saved.

Only for some: Limited Atonement, as this used to be called, meant that, when Christ died, it was only for a few people, and not everyone, as though grace were a physical object that, if left unclaimed, would float around in the ether as waste-grace. It's apparently also what God mean in John 3:16, when He used the word "whosoever.' Even though such a claim makes no sense, it shouldn't bother us, because we know God's ways are above ours.

Evil, through and through: This was called Total Depravity and was probably the most offensive of the five terms. The new name isn't any nicer, but this way, no one's wasting time trying to figure out what it means. It means that you're no good. Period.

You can't say no: When the Holy Spirit grabs you by the collar, you're not allowed or even able to resist Him. It fits back with point #1, that we're handpicked. You don't have a choice in the matter. You're just a machine.

Yes, that's right. H.O.O.E.Y. In my opinion, that's pretty much what it is. God gave it to us plain and simple: Live for Christ or die without him. The fact that we're told what to do implies we have a choice in the matter. All of these extra rules and regulations do nothing but plant hurdles between people and the Cross.

3 comments:

nate said...

I am in complete agreement with you. Good article and a good twist. You're always thought provoking. I'm linking you over at my site.

Remade Gold said...

Heretic. 0=)

Unknown said...

I came across your blog while browsing, and felt compelled to leave a comment. I know it's probably been said too many times before, but dead men don't make choices. We're all dead in our trespasses and sins; there's no way we can make our own choice about salvation (and why do we even deserve to offer Him our own "input", as you say?). Instead, God demonstrates His marvelous grace and chooses us for Himself. Not everybody is going to be saved; Christ said He came to die for those the Father had given Him. Remember, He's not only a God of love; He's a just God who hates and punishes sin.

If we had a choice in the matter, all of us would choose death and hell. It's our nature. Personally, I thank God that I didn't have a choice; that I can leave it all to Christ.

Calvinism doesn't reduce people to machines. We're already pretty much at that point naturally; we're slaves to sin. God graciously delivers us from that bondage; left to ourselves, we would continue in it like automatons.

As an aside, I'm not saying sinful people can't do "good" things from time to time, but their reasons for doing so are warped by their sin.

Christianity is not seeker-friendly. Never was, never will be. If we try to become seeker-friendly, we conform to and embrace the world. It's harsh, but it's truth.